Is the fee worth it? Run your own numbers.
Figures as of Nov 2026 · checked Nov 10, 2026A premium card is worth its fee when the credits you would have spent anyway, plus the rewards on your spending, add up to more than the fee. The calculator below uses each issuer's published fee, credits and earn rates as of Nov 2026. You decide which credits you'd really use and what a point is worth to you.
Credits you would really use
Your yearly spending (example numbers, change them)
1¢ is a simple baseline. Chase says points are worth $0.01 each in Chase Travel, and Capital One says 10,000 miles equal $100 toward travel. Transfer partners can be worth more or less, so use your own number.
The rates behind the calculator
| Card | Fee | Restaurants | U.S. supermarkets | Flights direct | Hotels via portal | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amex Platinum | $895 | 1 pt/$ | 1 pt/$ | 5 pts/$ (to $500K) | 5 pts/$ prepaid | 1 pt/$ |
| Amex Gold | $325 | 4 pts/$ (to $50K) | 4 pts/$ (to $25K) | 3 pts/$ | 5 pts/$ prepaid | 1 pt/$ |
| Sapphire Reserve | $795 | 3 pts/$ | 1 pt/$ | 4 pts/$ | 8 pts/$ Chase Travel | 1 pt/$ |
| Sapphire Preferred | $95 | 3 pts/$ | 1 pt/$ (3 pts/$ online grocery) | 2 pts/$ | 5 pts/$ Chase Travel | 1 pt/$ |
| Venture X | $395 | 2 pts/$ | 2 pts/$ | 2 pts/$ | 10 pts/$ Capital One Travel | 2 pts/$ |
These are simplified. The Sapphire Preferred earns 3 pts/$ on online grocery, but not at Target, Walmart or wholesale clubs. It also earns 3 pts/$ at gas stations and on select streaming. The calculator treats grocery spending as in-store. Category bonuses depend on how the merchant is coded, and the issuer doesn't control that.
How to read the result
- Be strict about credits. A $25 streaming credit is worth $25 only if you would pay for that service anyway. Otherwise it's worth $0 to you.
- Compare against your next-best card, not against nothing. The result shows what a 2% no-fee card would have earned on the same spending.
- Count each card once per household. A second cardholder doesn't double the credits unless the issuer says so.
Next: a five-question test for any annual fee, or what to do before the fee posts.
You pay for the black card. Get the black‑card treatment.
Card Butler is a private concierge for people who carry premium cards. It's run with our Credit Card Max bot, an AI concierge that tells you which card to swipe for your priorities. It keeps track of the credits and tells you whether to keep or cancel each card before the fee posts. It suggests and you approve. It never moves money.
Founding beta, still being built. What we describe is what the beta is working toward, not a finished app. Private beta: we scope it with you before any work starts. Billed yearly through Stripe.
Questions
How do I know if a credit card annual fee is worth it?
Add the credits you would have spent anyway to the rewards your spending earns, then subtract the fee. If the result beats what a no-fee card would earn on the same spending, the card is worth keeping.
Is this calculator connected to my bank?
No. It runs in your browser. Nothing you type is sent to Card Butler.
Sources
- American Express: The Platinum Card
- American Express: American Express Gold Card
- Chase: Sapphire Reserve
- Chase: Sapphire Preferred
- Capital One: Venture X
- Capital One newsroom: Venture X launch (10,000 anniversary miles equal to $100 toward travel)
Fees, credits and earn rates come from the issuer pages listed above, as of November 2026. Issuers change benefits and terms, so check the issuer's current terms before you rely on a figure. Card Butler is independent and isn't affiliated with, endorsed by or paid by any bank, card network or app mentioned here. We don't use affiliate links. This is information, not financial advice.